High Court to rule on O-Level rewrite

Grace Kaerasora and Veronica Gwaze
Two parents in Harare have approached the High Court to cancel the scheduled resitting of the November 2017 Ordinary Level English Language Paper 2 public examination.

In their urgent chamber application, Messrs Victor Mukomeka and Chingasiyeni Govhati argue that Primary and Secondary Education Minister Professor Paul Mavima breached constitutional provisions by annulling the results when only the Zimbabwe Schools Examinations Council could do so.

They want the resit conducted variably or to be cancelled altogether — a matter the court will likely determine early this week.

Prof Mavima and Zimsec will have to respond.

Government last week ordered over 260 000 candidates to resit the examination after widespread cheating had been detected. The resit is scheduled for this Friday.

English Language is among compulsory Ordinary Level subjects in Zimbabwe.

Messrs Mukomeka and Govhati are represented by Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights in collaboration with Justice for Children’s Trust.

Their application reads, in part: “(The examination) be declared null and void as the minister acted beyond his authority of which the Act empowers, in Section 34, only the examinations board to annul examination results.

“The minister confirms that the cheating was identified during the examination session. It is not clear why the English Paper 2 examination was allowed to continue, and why Zimsec proceeded to mark the exams, only to annul results on the 8th of February 2018, some months later.

“It is not clear why remedial action was not taken timeously and instantly upon realising the cheating or even the potential for cheating. Essentially, Zimsec allowed an exam in which they detected cheating to proceed and proceeded to mark it, only to annul results afterwards.

“The costs attached to this kind of action and the rationality and reasonableness of this decision alone does not withstand scrutiny.”

Prof Mavima could not be reached to comment on the lawsuit yesterday.

He had, however, told The Sunday Mail earlier that public examination cheats would soon be jailed and face a five-year ban from sitting national aptitude tests.

“We are not going back on what we have decided; people should give us time to implement what have decided. We are working on the entire system to ensure we restore integrity to the education system and deal with the entire value chain of the examination system.

“We will uproot all rot. Strict measures are required. So, we are saying no fine, but jail terms for those found guilty. I assure you the ministry and Zimsec are re-looking the system — from exam setting to distribution of exam material — as we are determined to find the culprits and remove them from our system.

“Exam cheating and leaks have dragged on for long; so there’s no turning back on these strict measures.”

Zimsec spokesperson Ms Nicolette Dhlamini added: “We are working together with the ministry to make sure these criminals are brought to book. Right now, structures are being put in place to ensure we uproot all the culprits. As of now, some have been taken to court.

“Although we have not yet compiled statistics, there was widespread cheating and some pupils were informed that their results had been cancelled. We are not going to allow those who were notified of results cancellation to sit for examinations in the next two to five years.

“So, English Language Paper 2 will be sat by everyone except those whose results were nullified. May all pupils be clearly informed that it is important for (candidates) to sit this exam as results for this subject will not be provided on the basis of Paper 1 performance only, but assessment for both Papers 1 and 2.”

Progressive Teachers’ Union of Zimbabwe president Dr Takavafira Zhou was livid.

“It is certainly ill-conceived and inappropriate. Instead, they could have simply used a normal distribution curve to give marks for the paper rather than waste resources on a subject that will have minimal effect on candidates’ results.

“When we told Zimsec and the ministry that there were exam leakages, they said it was localised. If re-writing was done well in 2017, it would have been more appropriate. However, ordering them to re-write three months down the line is ill-conceived and punishes many innocent students.

“Our real focus must be on closing leakages at Zimsec; printing, public and private schools. Heads must roll at Zimsec. Management slept on duty.”

46,775 total views, no views today

  • Cde Mzvinavhu(Prof)

    Control and risk management skills are very low or non existent in the public sector as a whole in this country. Fire fighting without overhauling the system is futile. Introduction of new technology requires orientation of those who administer exams to understand the necessary controls and risks in the systems. We have high degrees all over , some fake in ministries but zero skills. One wonders why the scramble to get PHDs all over the government, including the army and police , yet the actual relevant skills are not cultivated and encouraged. Our government needs to learn from other countries how they run their systems efficiently. Daily preaching sermons on the mountain is by no means what the public expects. Jesus Christ did it , but sinners continue sinning up to this day until he comes back .

  • Givemore Chivandaidze

    Its a disgrace for sure.We have a bunch of cheats being allowed to proceed with higher education. Corruption is being brewed at O’level upto Universities, then the very pple will find work in the government various department.

    Many schools are aware who cheated.Some school children in Many schools in Masvingo saw some students with exam papers seng thru social media. The rot is bigger than what is being said. Zimsec board cannot work on the matter but all must be fired or step down. Nobody leaks these exams except Zimsec members.
    Innocent parents and students being punished at the expense of known culprits.

  • Davis

    Out of the 260 000 students who sat for the English paper 2, how many had access to it before the exam? What percentage are we talking about and which schools, regions or districts were affected? What mechanism has now been put in place to ensure that what happened last year will not be repeated? So far the leakage hasn’t been fully explained as to how, where, when and with whom? Tipeiwo tsanangudzo nehumbowo huzere.Also the alleged culprits must respond otherwise manyepo. Someone is trying to be relevant by wasting resources and traumatizing our children.

  • Wezaka

    They didn’t sleep on duty, they made money, serious monies. If the board is not fired then we are not winning. This is more than corruption. We want to see ZACC sniffing on this, this is tampering with our patriotism and it should be stopped.

  • Tman zimbabwe

    Its a well organised network of criminals that its hard to know the culprit. It starts from the top brasse to surbodinates. Is this the first time? Mavhima has been there when it happened several times, no need to waste our time, pane zvaari kuvharavo zvake. He knows whats going on at zimsec.. Mari yakatopinda muhomwe kare.

  • T Justice Fushai

    “value chain” of the examination system… Lol its not economics Professor…. Your exam board is simply incompetent

  • Madara

    zimsec not worth anything these days anyways.